
Weekly Insight
Clip: Season 6 Episode 14 | 3m 57sVideo has Closed Captions
Representative Seth Magaziner will not move to the congressional district he represents.
Congressman Seth Magaziner faces criticism after announcing he won’t be moving to the congressional district that he represents despite previously pledging that he would. Rhode Island PBS Weekly’s Michelle San Miguel and WPRI 12’s Politics Editor Ted Nesi discuss why Magaziner decided not to move. They also explain the ongoing turmoil at South County Hospital.
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Rhode Island PBS Weekly is a local public television program presented by Rhode Island PBS

Weekly Insight
Clip: Season 6 Episode 14 | 3m 57sVideo has Closed Captions
Congressman Seth Magaziner faces criticism after announcing he won’t be moving to the congressional district that he represents despite previously pledging that he would. Rhode Island PBS Weekly’s Michelle San Miguel and WPRI 12’s Politics Editor Ted Nesi discuss why Magaziner decided not to move. They also explain the ongoing turmoil at South County Hospital.
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Rhode Island PBS Weekly
Rhode Island PBS Weekly is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- Ted, welcome back.
It's good to see you.
Congressman Seth Magaziner made what you can call an unexpected announcement to you and your colleague, Tim White, on Channel 12's Newsmakers, which is that he is going back on a pledge that he had made that he would move into the district that he represents.
- Yes, and it did take us by surprise on the show when he joined us that day, Michelle.
Viewers will probably remember when Congressman Magaziner ran for Congress, for the seat.
Jim Langevin was vacating in 2022.
Very tight race against Republican, Allan Fung, was getting national attention.
And one of the biggest knocks on Magaziner was, "You don't live in this district," you know, "If you wanna represent us, you should live here."
And he promised to move.
He said, "I pledge, I will be moving there with my family.
It's a tough housing market.
It might take some time, but we're gonna go there."
And then last fall, right before last year's election when he was up for reelection for the first time, Tim and I actually had discovered he had quietly moved his registration, which he had moved from the first to the second, was back in the first.
And so Tim went to him, said "What happened here?
I thought you were moving."
And he said, "Well, the renovations are taking a long time."
But now he's abandoned the idea he's moving altogether.
- Let's hear what Congressman Magaziner had to say about ultimately why he decided not to move into that district.
- My wife got a new job that requires her to commute to Cambridge, about a two hour commute.
We had a new baby.
And as you noted, the house in Cranston ended up needing a lot more work than we expected.
- For people who are saying that's an about face on your campaign promise?
- Our circumstances changed.
Sometimes in life, circumstances change.
And so I have to do what's best for my family.
- And no surprise here, Rhode Island State GOP Chairman was quick to criticize Magaziner for this about face, but I think the big question is ultimately what will voters have to say about this?
- Well, right Michelle.
I mean, we should be clear.
This is legal.
You don't have to live, if you're in the US house, you don't have to live in the exact district you represent.
You just need to live in the state you represent.
And there are some other examples of lawmakers who live a little outside the district lines, but at the same time, as you said, he pledged to voters he would move.
And he has walked that back.
And so he isn't up for reelection until the end of next year in the midterms.
And so there's a long time to go before he vases voters.
But you know, I've covered politics a long time, Michelle.
It's not hard to imagine how an opponent would make a TV attack ad out of this controversy.
- Right, saying something like "Broken Promise, Seth Magaziner."
- Exactly.
We've all seen it.
Yes, exactly.
- Yeah.
Let's turn now to a topic that we've talked about a lot here on "Weekly Insight", which is healthcare, specifically the ongoing turmoil at South County Hospital.
For viewers who are not familiar, what's happening there?
- Well, so South County Hospital is something rare these days, Michelle, an independently owned and operated hospital in Rhode Island.
All the others are part of bigger systems, Rhode Island systems, or even out of state systems.
And it's always had a good reputation all the years that I've been a reporter in Rhode Island, but for months now, the hospital's executives have been facing quite a bit of criticism from outside advocates who say they're supporters of the hospital, as well as some of their own staff.
They've criticized them for alleged financial mismanagement, for being sort of imperious, and a lack of good leadership.
And it's now escalated to the point where the hospital is actually suing the advocacy group, South County Hospital, that's been putting all this pressure on them.
- And this comes as leaders in Rhode Island's healthcare sector have already been sounding the alarm about the financial strains that they're feeling.
And ultimately, they're worried about the future of the industry.
- Yes, and that's actually part of what makes this a surprising situation, Michelle, because South County, unlike most of the hospitals in Rhode Island, has a relatively large percentage of its patients who have commercial insurance, which pays better.
Attorney General, Peter Neronha has pointed that out, too.
That should have been good for its bottom line, but South County's been losing millions of dollars a year, which is why one of the reasons all this criticism has come to the fore.
I should note executives at the hospital say
Video has Closed Captions
How the Washington Bridge debacle inspired a new ice cream called crumbling bridge. (3m 50s)
Video has Closed Captions
From North Providence hoopster to P-C star to NBA Rookie of the Year. The story of Ernie D. (9m 26s)
Video has Closed Captions
The Washington Bridge taking an economic toll on one of Rhode Island’s biggest industries (8m 56s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Rhode Island PBS Weekly is a local public television program presented by Rhode Island PBS